Jump To Navigation

Case Law

CSX Transportation v. Robert V. Gilkison

Date Decided: July 30th, 2009
Originally Filed in: West Virginia (Federal)
Decided by: West Virginia Northern District Court (Federal)
Court: U.S.D.C. Northern District of West Virginia
Judge: Judge Stamp Jr.
Citation: 2009 WL2357142 (N.D.W.Va.)

CSX Transportation, ("CSX") brought action against defendants, Robert V. Gilkison ("Gilkison") and Pierce, Raimond & Coulter, P.C. ("The Pierce Firm") alleging that the defendants knowingly and negligently added client, Ricky May, in pursuing a fraudulent asbestosis claim against CSX. Before this Court were Motions for Summary Judgment filed by the plaintiff and defendants. On June 13, 200, Danny Jayne, a CSX employee who had tested positive for asbestosis, attended a Pierce Firm screening allegedly impersonating Ricky May, an employee whom had tested negative for asbestosis. Gilkison, an employee of the Pierce Firm, was present at the screening to assist and facilitate the screening process. The fraudulent X-ray was then used to support a claim by Mr. May against CSX in a lawsuit filed pursuant to the Federal Employer Liability Act ("FELA"). CSX settled Mr. May's claim for $8,000. The Plaintiff and Defendants both filed for motions of summary judgment.

Should the Court grant defendants' or plaintiff's motion(s) for summary judgment?

A motion for summary judgment will be granted if the moving party can show, construing facts in favor of the non-moving party, that there exists no genuine issues of material facts and that they must be granted judgment as a matter of law. CSX contends that Gilkison's deposition testimony established his affirmative knowledge of the fraud. Furthermore, CSX contends that because Gilkison is an employee of the Pierce Firm and that if the individual is an agent and if he was acting within the scope of the employment when he committed the tort, the principle, The Pierce Firm, is liable for the tort as well. The Pierce Firm contended that CSX's fraud claim is barred by the statute of limitations. CSX filed suit three years after becoming aware of the fraud which was one year after the applicable statute of limitations had run. Under West Virginia Law, the essential elements for fraud are: (1) The act of fraud was committed by the defendant (2) that it was material and false (3) that the plaintiff relied upon the misrepresentation and was justified in relying upon it and (4) the plaintiff was damaged because he relied upon it. This Court held that genuine issues of material fact remain in the case, whether CSX's fraud claim is barred by the applicable statute of limitations, whether Gilkison had knowledge of the fraud, acted reasonably, and in the scope of his employment duties as to impute any knowledge of fraud to the Pierce Firm. Accordingly, this Court denied CSX's motion for Summary Judgment. Furthermore, because the Pierce Firm advances motions for summary judgment that require the a fact finder to determine the above mentioned facts, their motions are denied.

A claim for fraud must be pleaded with particularity and, as demonstrated, moving for summary judgment on a fraud claim requires the Court to find as a matter of law for the moving party because there were no genuine issues of material fact. Combining the requirements to plead a fraud claim with those of a summary judgment motion make fraud a difficult claim to be granted summary judgment upon.

Steve Gordon


CSX Transportation

Overall issues discussed or touched upon by this case:
Free Case Evaluation Form Talk to a Lawyer Now
Please complete the math to prove you are not a robot:
in-depth overview FELA click here


In re Ricky Joe Jones, Cheryl Ann Jones, Debtors

Date Decided: Jan 25th, 2011
Decided By: U.S. Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit(Bankruptcy) (Federal) read more

Leandrew Lewis v. CSX Transportation, Inc.

Date Decided: Mar 10th, 2011
Decided By: Ohio Southern District Court (Federal) read more

Subscribe to Case Law Feed


Train Carrying Crude Oil Derails Causing Explosion & Fire in Alabama Wetlands

 ALICEVILLE, AL – A train carrying tanker cars full of crude oil derailed on November 8 causing an explosion and fire in a wetlands area just outside Aliceville, AL. The city of Aliceville is... read more

Railroad Worker Injured in Midvale, Utah TRAX Train Crash

 MIDVALE, UT – A TRAX commuter train crashed into an empty passenger car that was sitting on the tracks on November 6, derailing the train and injuring two passengers and a railroad employee in... read more

CSX Train Derails in Millcreek Township, PA

 MILLCREEK TOWNSHIP, PA – Four CSX rail cars full of construction debris derailed in Millcreek Township, PA on November 1, causing traffic delays at several intersections. Millcreek Township is... read more

Three CSX Railroad Workers One Motorist Injured at Bradner, OH Rail Crossing

 BRADNER, OH – Three CSX railroad employees were injured at a rail crossing just south of Bradner, OH on October 28, when a motorist drove around construction barriers and hit a utility pole and... read more

Subscribe RSS
Attorneys Refer your cases here

Toll-Free: 800-773-6770
Local: 713-668-9999
Fax: 713-668-1980
1811 Bering Drive, Suite 300
Houston, TX 77057

Of Counsel Offices

David Lockard
15 W Highland Ave
Philadelphia, PA 19118

Fred Bremseth
Minnesota Office
601 Carlson Parkway
Suite 995
Minnetonka, Minnesota 55305

Montana Office
100 North 27th Street
Suite 220
Billings, Montana 59101