Jump To Navigation

Case Law

In re BNSF Railway Company

Date Decided: December 31st, 2009
Originally Filed in: ()
Decided by: (State)
Court: Court of Appeals of Texas
Judge: Judge McKeithen, Judge Kreger, Judge Horton
Citation: 2009 WL 5214907 (Tex.App.-Beaumont)

Background:
BNSF Railway Company filed a petition to compel the trial court to vacate its order compelling production of documents in a suit filed under the Federal Employers' Liability Act, FELA. BNSF claimed the trial court abused its discretion by ordering BNSF to respond to discovery requests on matters not relevant to the subject matter of the suit. BNSF claimed that the trial court ordered them to produce documents not in their possession and undiscoverable by statute. Charles Simmons, the plaintiff, alleged that during the course of his employment as a conductor with BSNSF he suffered repetitive trauma to his hands, arms, shoulders, back, and neck. The trial court ordered BNSF to produce a list showing the number of injuries, claims, and lawsuits filed by conducters alleging repetitive trauma injuries similar to Simmons's.

Issues:
Did the trial court abuse its discretion by ordering BNSF to produce documents related to previous claims made by conductors under FELA?

Held:
This Court recognized that requests for discovery must show a reasonable expectation of obtaining information that will aid the dispute's resolution and therefore must be reasonably tailored to include only relevant matters. This Court found that the discovery requests at issue in this case were not sufficiently specific regarding the documents being requested. The first request for production includes the language "any and all" of a vast variety of different sorts of information from "whatever source derived" etc... The request for production of documents contained no geographical limitation, no limitation as to time period or source. The second request for production narrowed the time frame to a 10-year period but requested "any and all" of a wide variety of information and media "filed with" the railroad, including and not limited to "accident forms". The third request fails to limit to BNSF or to persons under its control and requests production from "any organization" with which the railroad is "associated" with. Accordingly, in light of the broad discovery requests, that failed to describe with particularity each item and category requested, this court granted the petition for writ of mandamus and vacated the trial court's ruling.

Comments:
The scope of discovery is generally within the trial court's discretion, the trial court must make an effort to impose reasonable discovery limits. If the trial court orders discovery that exceeds what is permitted by the rules of discovery, then it is an abuse of discretion. Steve Gordon

<< PREVNEXT >>

In re BNSF Railway Company

Overall issues discussed or touched upon by this case:
Free Case Evaluation Form Talk to a Lawyer Now
Please complete the math to prove you are not a robot:
=
in-depth overview FELA click here

LATEST CASE LAWS

In re Ricky Joe Jones, Cheryl Ann Jones, Debtors

Date Decided: Jan 25th, 2011
Decided By: U.S. Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit(Bankruptcy) (Federal) read more

Leandrew Lewis v. CSX Transportation, Inc.

Date Decided: Mar 10th, 2011
Decided By: Ohio Southern District Court (Federal) read more

Subscribe to Case Law Feed

LATEST RAILROAD NEWS

Train Carrying Crude Oil Derails Causing Explosion & Fire in Alabama Wetlands

 ALICEVILLE, AL – A train carrying tanker cars full of crude oil derailed on November 8 causing an explosion and fire in a wetlands area just outside Aliceville, AL. The city of Aliceville is... read more

Railroad Worker Injured in Midvale, Utah TRAX Train Crash

 MIDVALE, UT – A TRAX commuter train crashed into an empty passenger car that was sitting on the tracks on November 6, derailing the train and injuring two passengers and a railroad employee in... read more

CSX Train Derails in Millcreek Township, PA

 MILLCREEK TOWNSHIP, PA – Four CSX rail cars full of construction debris derailed in Millcreek Township, PA on November 1, causing traffic delays at several intersections. Millcreek Township is... read more

Three CSX Railroad Workers One Motorist Injured at Bradner, OH Rail Crossing

 BRADNER, OH – Three CSX railroad employees were injured at a rail crossing just south of Bradner, OH on October 28, when a motorist drove around construction barriers and hit a utility pole and... read more

Subscribe RSS
Attorneys Refer your cases here

Toll-Free: 800-773-6770
Local: 713-668-9999
Fax: 713-668-1980
1811 Bering Drive, Suite 300
Houston, TX 77057

Of Counsel Offices

David Lockard
15 W Highland Ave
Philadelphia, PA 19118

Fred Bremseth
Minnesota Office
601 Carlson Parkway
Suite 995
Minnetonka, Minnesota 55305

Montana Office
100 North 27th Street
Suite 220
Billings, Montana 59101